I realise this may be obvious to most but I think it bears repeating-a no. 1 bestselling book-with,of course,some notable exceptions,will usually not be very good!
Its no different to most other things that are popular.
As far as erotica is concerned,if youre a man,just read The Marquis de Sades books and have done with it!!
After that everything is tame.
But,BY FAR,the worst books published imho,are crime books.
Dont get me wrong,there are many good ones-I love Scandinavian crime books,but there are some that actually get to no 1 and you read them out of curiosity and you think,WOW-any cunt could have written this crap!
The plots are so stupid,the characters one-dimensional,the fight scenes numerous and tedious and there is a breathtaking lack of suspense-I mean,FFS,surely either there must be suspense OR a great plot OR an interesting detective!!??
And I guess thats the essence of whether a book is good or not.
If you believe that it could have been written by many other people...then its crap....but if you feel it could only have been written by that author,or maybe a few others,its probably good
As far as womens erotica is concerned,I must admit ODM made me smile when he said that the sex was tame and it was mostly talking!!
YEP,thats what womens erotica is,isnt it?
Not to mention married life.