• Hi and welcome to Betnod. Please register for even more tips, analysis and chat.

I Know The Score 2018/19 - Paid Entry

Just to get it straight in my mind. [For my spreadsheet presentation]
Have we come to any decision for eliminating two players in Champions League or we going by Rc's suggestion.
I agree with him GW27 [FA Cup week] should not be the deciding week but perhaps scores from those five games can be combined with scores from GW28 to eliminate two players.


Thanks
 
Last edited by a moderator:
newman200 said:
Have we come to any decision for eliminating two players in Champions League or we going by Rc's suggestion.
I agree with him GW27 [FA Cup week] should not be the deciding week but perhaps scores from those five games can be combined with scores from GW28 to eliminate two players.
Click to expand...

Think you've misunderstood me, Newman. I do think GW27 should be the deciding week. The rules say the tie-break will be held in the following game week, which is GW27 in this case, I can't see any logical reason to change that from GW27 to GW28.

At the end of the day, it's just a tie-break to separate any players that are on the same score, nothing more. Obviously the more games there are, the better the chances of separating the players, but 5 games gives plenty of scope for separating them (and it still leaves the opportunity, if there are still 2 or more players tied), to use GW28 as a further tie-break).

My vote would go to GW27 being used.
 
rcgills said:
Think you've misunderstood me, Newman. I do think GW27 should be the deciding week. The rules say the tie-break will be held in the following game week, which is GW27 in this case, I can't see any logical reason to change that from GW27 to GW28.

At the end of the day, it's just a tie-break to separate any players that are on the same score, nothing more. Obviously the more games there are, the better the chances of separating the players, but 5 games gives plenty of scope for separating them (and it still leaves the opportunity, if there are still 2 or more players tied), to use GW28 as a further tie-break).

My vote would go to GW27 being used.
Click to expand...
I'm happy just with GW27.

BTW perhaps I'm misreading rules but is GW28 redundant?
"(In the event of a tie in the league or in the semi finals a head to head in the following gameweek, will decide who goes through. In the rare event of a further tie here, it would be decided by who sits highest in the BPL league at present time, as it would should the final be a tie)".
 
Yes, you're right Newman, if we're going by the rules, then GW28 wouldn't come into play.
 
Totlally agree with RC.
It makes sense to make GW27 the deciding week and if anybody is still level after that I'd say we use GW28 as another decider while its a free week but as rules are rules then it's who sits highest in BPL I suppose as Newman mentions.
 
Gameweek 27

upload_2019-3-17_19-53-9.png
 
Last edited by a moderator:
First leg of the Champions League semis this week, isn't it? Good luck, Newman :beer
 
rcgills said:
First leg of the Champions League semis this week, isn't it? Good luck, Newman :beer
Click to expand...

It is indeed.
I have already added this Comp to my regular spreadsheets.
Good luck to all four of us.

BTW I notice that you have gone into early lead with use of Bonus.
My Bonus tw is still to be played on Chelsea/West Ham match.
Daft I know: London derbies usually end as draws and I have Chelsea to win :ohwell
 
newman200 said:
It is indeed.
I have already added this Comp to my regular spreadsheets.
Good luck to all four of us.

BTW I notice that you have gone into early lead with use of Bonus.
My Bonus tw is still to be played on Chelsea/West Ham match.
Daft I know: London derbies usually end as draws and I have Chelsea to win :ohwell
Click to expand...

I was between Leicester or Chelsea for the banker bonus, ended up going with Leicester. I'll still be backing Chelsea to win tomorrow but given what's at stake, I wouldn't now be too disappointed if they don't actually win!
 
I'd expect most narrowed it down to Leicester or Chelsea with Leicester being the riskier bet as it's away from home albeit a x 3.

I wouldn't at all be surprised to see most of us dipping tomorrow (Monday) on Chelsea but out of the two it seemed the safer bet imo.
 
Thought a few more might have been on Leicester tonight with their BB as it must have been on quite a few peoples shortlist but it looks like only Cleggy and Villamick have succumbed.

I'm fearing the worst now because every time Cleggy loses his BB every other bastard seems to lose theirs too.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top